Bumble and Bumble vs Aveda (The Definitive Guide)

In today's comparison, we're getting to the nitty-gritty of two cult-favorite haircare lines: Bumble and Bumble and Aveda.

Specifically, we're comparing their two leave-in treatments, both boasting impressive benefits: the Bumble and Bumble Hairdresser's Invisible Oil Heat/UV Protective Primer and the Aveda Nutriplenish Leave-In Conditioner.

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Bumble and Bumble vs. Aveda: A Science-Based Look into Hair Primers

Core Ingredients

Bumble and Bumble's 6-Oil Blend

Let's dive in! The Bumble and Bumble Hairdresser's Invisible Oil Heat/UV Protective Primer, an all-around favorite, promises to reduce frizz, detangle, soften, shine, and protect your locks from the heat and UV rays. It's all thanks to its featherlight 6-Oil Blend.

Coconut Oil: This oil is high in lauric acid, a type of fatty acid known for its deep penetrative properties. This makes it excellent for hydrating the hair shaft and sealing in moisture. It's also a great source of Vitamin E, known for its antioxidant properties, meaning it can help protect your hair from environmental damage.

Argan Oil: Often dubbed "liquid gold," Argan oil is packed with beneficial components like Vitamin E, antioxidants, and fatty acids. It can help to moisturize hair, reduce breakage, and give your locks a shiny finish.

Grape Seed Oil: This oil is rich in linoleic acid, an omega-6 fatty acid, which can promote hair health and shine. It's also known for its ability to lock in moisture and prevent frizz, split ends, and brittle hair.

Macadamia Oil: High in monounsaturated fats, this oil is excellent for hair hydration, repair, and protection. It can help to strengthen hair, preventing hair breakage by penetrating the scalp and hair follicles.

Sweet Almond Oil: This oil is loaded with essential nutrients such as proteins, Vitamin E, and B vitamins, helping to strengthen hair and leave it with a high-gloss finish.

Safflower Seed Oil: This lesser-known oil is packed with oleic acid, which can stimulate hair growth and strength. It also contributes to a smooth, shiny appearance.

Aveda's Symphony of Nature-Inspired Powerhouses

Aveda's Nutriplenish Leave-In Conditioner, on the other hand, is all about hydration and replenishment for 72 hours, along with thermal and UV protection. And, it's 98% naturally derived, vegan, and free of silicones and sulfates. Sounds like a win, right?

Hydrolyzed Adansonia Digitata (Baobab) Extract: Baobab is known for its hydrating properties due to its high vitamin content. It's packed with vitamins A, D, E, and F, which can help rejuvenate damaged hair and increase hair strength and elasticity.

Punica Granatum (Pomegranate) Seed Oil: Pomegranate Seed Oil is rich in punicic acid, a type of fatty acid known for its potent moisturizing properties. This can help to revitalize and strengthen hair, while also enhancing the luster and texture of your locks.

Kaempferia Galanga Root Extract: Also known as aromatic ginger, Kaempferia Galanga has been used traditionally in Asian cultures for its hair and skin benefits. This root extract contains ethereal oils and flavonoids, which can offer antioxidative properties to protect hair from environmental stressors.

Chondrus Crispus (Carrageenan) Extract: Extracted from red seaweed, Carrageenan is an excellent natural conditioner. It forms a flexible film on the hair, helping to moisturize, smooth, and protect the hair shaft from damage. It also gives a boost to hair's elasticity and resilience.

Hydrolyzed Jojoba Esters: Hydrolyzed Jojoba Esters are derived from jojoba oil. This ingredient benefits hair by providing moisture, improving hair elasticity, strengthening the hair shaft, and enhancing shine. The hydrolyzed form enables these benefits to be delivered deep into the hair fiber for optimal hydration and health.

Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower) Seed Oil: Sunflower Seed Oil is high in Vitamin E and oleic acid, a monounsaturated fatty acid. These components make it a natural hydrator, adding shine, and nourishing the hair. It also provides excellent protection against UV radiation and environmental damage.

The Conditioning Champions

Behentrimonium Methosulfate

Both the Bumble and Bumble Primer and the Aveda Leave-In Conditioner have Behentrimonium Methosulfate as one of their key conditioning agents.

This ingredient is derived from Rapeseed oil and is one of the mildest detangling ingredients out there. It is a quaternary ammonium compound, or "quat" for short, known for their superior detangling capabilities.

Behentrimonium Methosulfate doesn't cause buildup and is gentle enough even for use in baby products. It conditions hair by coating and penetrating the hair shaft, leading to improved combability, shine, and reduced static.

Dimethicone in Bumble and Bumble

Bumble and Bumble's primer includes Dimethicone, a type of silicone that's commonly used in haircare products. Dimethicone coats the hair shaft, providing a protective layer that can help minimize damage from environmental factors and heat styling.

It also imparts a smooth, silky feel to the hair, reduces frizz, and adds significant shine. However, it's worth noting that for some hair types, particularly those prone to buildup, the use of silicones like Dimethicone can sometimes lead to heaviness and reduced volume over time.

Sclerotium Gum in Aveda

On the other hand, Aveda's leave-in conditioner features Sclerotium Gum, a plant-derived conditioning agent. This natural thickening agent is produced by a type of bacteria that ferments glucose.

In haircare products, Sclerotium Gum functions as a conditioner and detangler. It forms a protective, moisturizing layer around the hair shaft, promoting a silky, soft feel and reducing frizz. Unlike synthetic conditioning agents like silicones, Sclerotium Gum is completely biodegradable and less likely to cause buildup, making it an excellent choice for those preferring more natural-based haircare solutions.

In sum, while both products contain potent conditioning agents, your choice may depend on your preference for synthetic (Bumble and Bumble) versus natural (Aveda) ingredients, and how your hair typically responds to each.

Vegan & Cruelty-Free Status

While both brands are cruelty-free, there’s a difference in their approach to veganism. Bumble and Bumble is not fully vegan, while Aveda's leave-in is vegan and 98% naturally derived, a point to consider for those adhering to plant-based lifestyles.

Sun and Heat Protection

Both treatments provide heat and UV protection, crucial for maintaining the health of your hair, especially if it’s frequently styled with heat tools or exposed to sunlight.

So, How Do We Choose Between the Two?

Choosing between the Bumble and Bumble Hairdresser's Invisible Oil Heat/UV Protective Primer and the Aveda Nutriplenish Leave-In Conditioner can be a bit like choosing between two exquisite pieces of art — they're both stunning in their own ways.

Your ultimate decision will likely come down to your individual hair needs, your product preferences, and your own personal ethos when it comes to beauty products.

Look at your hair needs. If your hair is particularly dry, frizzy, or hard to manage, Bumble and Bumble's blend of six oils might provide that deep hydration and smoothing effect you're looking for. If, on the other hand, your hair needs protection from UV and heat damage while also requiring some lightweight hydration, Aveda's nature-inspired concoction might be the winner.

Consider your product preferences. Bumble and Bumble's Hairdresser's Invisible Oil offers a heavier, oil-based formula that can offer substantial frizz control and heat protection. Meanwhile, Aveda's leave-in conditioner provides a more lightweight, water-based formula that offers hydration without weighing your hair down.

Reflect on your personal ethos. Are you someone who prefers natural, plant-based ingredients in your haircare products? If so, Aveda's Nutriplenish Leave-In Conditioner, with its focus on naturally-derived ingredients, may align more closely with your philosophy. Alternatively, if you're less concerned about ingredient origins and more focused on performance and results, Bumble and Bumble's Hairdresser's Invisible Oil could be the right pick.

In the end, the decision is deeply personal. Both products offer fantastic benefits and contain scientifically-backed ingredients that are known to nourish, protect, and enhance the health and appearance of your hair. You may even find that alternating between the two, depending on your hair's needs at any given time, could offer the best of both worlds!

Other Bumble and Bumble Best-Sellers

For daily washing:
Try Gentle Shampoo

For volumizing hair:
Try Thickening Volume

For detoxifying hair:
Try Sunday Shampoo

Other Aveda Best-Sellers

For smoothness:
Try Smooth Infusion

For color-treated hair:
Try Color Conserve

For hair growth:
Try Invati Advanced