Sisley vs La Prairie 2024 (The Definitive Guide)

We're positive you've seen—or at the very least heard of—Sisley and La Prairie before. But how do they compare? And which is best for you?

Having recently covered La Mer vs La Prairie and La Mer vs Sisley, it only made sense to complete the trilogy by comparing Sisley vs La Prairie. So, today we'll be doing precisely that, concluding once and for all which ultra-high-end skincare brand better suits you!

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Sisley vs La Prairie Moisturizer

First up, we have La Prairie’s Skin Caviar Luxe Cream, which already sounds tempting just from its name alone. With this cream, the formula aims to deliver impressive results by lifting and firming the skin, as well as supporting its moisture levels. It’s aimed at those looking for a tighter, firmer complexion from their daily skincare routine.

In this moisturizer, the feature ingredient is Caviar, a well-known prestigious delicacy (which is now in your facial creams, too, apparently!). La Prairie have utilised innovative scientific techniques to extract the most powerful components of this delicacy, and bioengineered the formula to benefit your skin.

Not many products can stand alongside the La Prairie fan-favourite, but Sisley's Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream has also earned its spot at the top. If you deal with sensitive skin, enjoy a thinner layer of cream under your makeup, or find yourself in warmer weather, this cream is calling your name.

With both of these products performing highly, excellent reviews all around, and plenty of happy customers, it’s difficult to decide which is better. Ultimately, the biggest difference between these two luxury products is their price. Neither are cheap, per se, but for the inimitable anti-ageing benefits boasted by La Prairie's cream, you should be prepared to pay up to 5 times as much as its Sisley counterpart. In our opinion, the results of La Prarie's Skin Caviar Luxe Cream makes it oh so worth the splurge - BUT, if you're just looking for a high quality day cream suited to all skin types (sans the anti-ageing perks), definitely don't overlook Sisley's Black Rose Skin Infusion Cream.

Sisley vs La Prairie Cleanser

Up next, it’s time to look at another step in the Sisley vs La Prairie skincare regime, and that’s the cleansers: Sisley's Soapless Gentle Foaming Cleanser and La Prairie's Foam Cleanser. Once again, these are both luxury goods (being from the same brands, this is a given), and they’re also on the pricier side. 

Despite both cleansers having a foam texture, neither product contains soap! This means that they are ideal for all skin types, as they are both super delicate on your skin.

Made from 100% natural-origin active ingredients, the Soapless Gentle Foaming Cleanser formula stays true to Sisley’s brand values, delivering a quality plant-based product that works for anybody and everybody.

Similarly, La Prairie’s Foam Cleanser is said to dissolve your makeup, leaving no trace, while maintaining your moisture balance, allowing your skin to hit refresh with a more calming feeling. The product is lightly scented, which many people can often feel slightly wary about. While fragrances can have negative effects for your skin, its presence in a wash-off product like this isn’t so severe, and fragrance shouldn’t be too much of a problem. 

If you have dry to very dry skin, you might want to give Sisley a shot at winning you over first; if a little bit of added fragrance is not a concern to you, though, we highly recommend La Prairie's Foam Cleanser, as it delivers a much more luxury, sweet-scented experience. 

Sisley vs La Prairie Eye Cream

La Prairie’s Skin Caviar Luxe Eye Cream has a very similar formula to its sister product, the Skin Caviar Luxe Cream, as they both feature the same exclusive ingredient - derived from Swiss caviar - which has been engineered and modified to provide you with the most indulgent, effective experience. Once again, this cream strives to moisturise the eye area, whilst diminishing puffiness as well as tightening and toning the area of skin around the eyes, reducing the visible signs of ageing. 

Featuring a significantly more affordable price point is Sisley’s Botanical Eye and Lip Contour Balm. This gem of an eye cream instead focusses more on providing you with a well-rested look by de-puffing the under-eye area, whilst also smoothing the surrounding skin, and correcting fine lines and wrinkles.

Unlike our conclusion with regards to their moisturizers, we much prefer Sisley's Botanical Eye and Lip Contour Balm overall here. Since it boasts competitive anti-ageing benefits relative to La Prairie's Eye Cream (which is usually La Prairie's overriding winning factor), it makes the higher price point feel a lot less warranted. Thus, we thoroughly recommend opting for Sisley when it comes to treating your eye area.

Sisley vs La Prairie Conclusion

The consensus with regards to the two brands as a whole follows neatly from the inferences we drew from the moisturizer comparison. To reiterate, both brands absolutely excel in delivering top-notch quality and unique skin-nourishing experiences. When it comes to deciding between the two, the biggest difference is the fact that La Prairie caters more towards ageing skin types, whereas Sisley targets all skin types with their products. Whichever you decide to go for, though, be confident in the knowledge that *both* are serious cult-favorites, with thousands of rave reviews vouching for them.

So as not to ramble on forever, this article comprised comparisons of the most popular, best-selling products from the two brands. To round off our review, though, here are our recommendations for the alternative skincare products that Sisley and La Prairie offer.

Other Sisley Products

For ageing skin:
Try the L'Integral Cream

For hydration:
Try the Express Flower Gel

For overnight results:
Try the Velvet Sleeping Mask

Other La Prairie Products

For skin softening:
Try the Softening Lotion

For glowing skin:
Try the Crystalline Concentre

For overnight results:
Try the Sleep Mask

Work in progress

You have been reading a post that we are constantly updating. Be sure to bookmark this page, subscribe, and come back later to see additions to the definitive Sisley vs La Prairie guide!

This article was originally published on February 2nd 2022, but it has been reviewed and updated with the latest available information on January 26th 2024 by Sara Mckay, MA.