Paul Mitchell vs Biolage (The Definitive Guide)

You’ve likely seen Paul Mitchell and Biolage products on your social media feed before, or perhaps you’ve seen them at your favorite hair salon. Both are highly sought after, but which brand should you use?

If you're thinking about giving them a try, check out this comprehensive guide to find out which cult-favorite hair system is better.

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Paul Mitchell vs Biolage Shampoo

A great shampoo is one that effectively cleanses your hair fibres whilst delivering special care for any specific hair concerns you might have (e.g. volume, shine, moisture, etc.). I don't think there's a single person out there that would dispute the fact that Paul Mitchell and Biolage shampoos are some of the best in this regard, and there are dozens to choose from. Fundamentally, though, there are a few key differences to note.

The Paul Mitchell Tea Tree Special Shampoo is Paul Mitchell’s number one best selling product, which speaks volumes about the shampoo’s effectiveness. It deeply cleanses the scalp and invigorates it with a soft, tingly sensation.

The formula is infused with a blend of tea tree, peppermint, and lavender which cools and cleanses, leaving a calming scent behind. This natural infusion fights dandruff and moisturizes the scalp.

Furthermore, the shampoo arrives in gorgeous dark green packaging with a handy pump for ease of use. This packaging is 100% sustainable and the product is proud to be vegan and cruelty-free.

The Paul Mitchell shampoo has three sizing options: a 10.1 fl oz bottle for $16.50, a 16.9 fl oz bottle for $25.50, or a full-size 33.8 fl oz bottle for $41.50.

Another great alternative is the Biolage Scalp Sync Shampoo. This anti-dandruff formula relieves irritation and gently detoxifies the scalp and hair. This hydrating shampoo is great to use in the wintertime when our hair and skin are at their driest.

The key ingredient is Pyrithione Zinc, which treats itchy, flaking scalp, revealing smooth, irritated skin. The shampoo also contains menthol, which stimulates blood circulation and encourages hair regrowth.

The packaging has been created from recycled materials, and the formula also contains no animal-derived ingredients and it is cruelty-free.

The Biolage Scalp Sync Shampoo retails for $23 for a 13.5 fl oz bottle or $38 for a 33.8 fl oz bottle.

Paul Mitchell vs Biolage Conditioner

Akin to cleansing your skin, washing your hair is a critical step, but in doing so you are stripping it of moisture, and you need to replace that moisture by using a conditioner—just like you would for your skin with a moisturizer! As far as conditioners go, there's not too many as good as those by Paul Mitchell and Biolage.

The Paul Mitchell Tea Tree Special Conditioner helps to smooth, detangle, and nourish the hair and scalp. The conditioner contains powerful botanicals that revitalize the hair and provide long-lasting hydration.

The calming blend of lavender, tea tree, and peppermint provides an aromatherapeutic experience in the shower. The formula is color-safe and paraben-free, which means it won’t dry out your precious hair over time.

For the Tea Tree conditioner, you can get 10.1 fl oz for $18, 16.9 fl oz for $27, or 33.8 fl oz for $44.50.

Our final product is the Biolage Scalp Sync Conditioner. This creamy conditioner strengthens the hair and injects moisture from root to tip.

After shampooing, apply the product throughout your hair and leave it to work its magic for up to 3 minutes, before rinsing. This hydrating formula fights hair knots and makes your hair much easier to brush showering.

This vegan conditioner is enriched with Cola Nitida Seed Extract, which controls frizz and softens. The ingredients list also includes Potato Starch which reduces hair loss and refortifies the hair from the inside out.

You can pick up a 13.5 fl oz bottle for $23, or a 33.8 fl oz bottle for $38.

Paul Mitchell vs Biolage Conclusion

After thoroughly reviewing both brands, we've decided that Paul Mitchell is the better choice. Compared to Biolage, the Tea Tree shampoo and conditioner have more natural ingredients, prettier packaging, and three sizes to suit everyone’s budget.

To round off our review, here are our recommendations for the best-selling ranges and products that Paul Mitchell and Biolage offer.

Paul Mitchell Best-Sellers

For conscious haircare:
Try Clean Beauty

For everyday wash:
Try the Shampoo One

For oily hair:
Try the Shampoo Two

Biolage Best-Sellers

For very dry hair:
Try Ultra Hydra Source

For fine hair:
Try Volume Bloom

For oily hair:
Try Scalp Sync