Drunk Elephant Umbra Tinte vs Umbra Sheer (The Definitive Guide)

Today we are diving into a comparison of two fantastic sunscreens by Drunk Elephant: Umbra Tinte Physical Daily Defense SPF 30 and Umbra Sheer Physical Daily Defense SPF 30.

With summer just around the corner, it's time to ensure you're keeping your skin protected and radiant. Let's discover which one of these sunscreens might be your new best friend.

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Drunk Elephant Umbra Tinte vs Umbra Sheer

Drunk Elephant Umbra Tinte: “The Glow-Getter”

This tinted physical sunscreen not only provides UVA/UVB protection but also helps prevent free radical and oxidative damage. Its unique tint gives your skin a beautiful, glowing finish, making it perfect for those who want a little extra something in their sunscreen.

The Umbra Tinte is packed with potent antioxidants like Astaxanthin, Grape Juice, and Sunflower Shoot Extract to minimize the appearance of photoaging, ensuring a more youthful-looking complexion. Raspberry Seed and Marula oils keep your skin moisturized and help minimize the look of fine lines and wrinkles.

Suitable for all skin types, including the most sensitive, this sunscreen is formulated without any chemical sunscreens or silicones. Its universally flattering tint works well on all skin tones.

Find the best Umbra Tinte prices on Amazon

Drunk Elephant Umbra Sheer: “The Invisible Shield”

Umbra Sheer, on the other hand, is a sheer (who would've guessed!?) physical sunscreen that delivers broad-spectrum UVA/UVB protection and helps prevent free radical and oxidative damage. Like Umbra Tinte, it's loaded with antioxidants (the same ones, actually!) to minimize photoaging and contains Raspberry Seed and Marula oils to moisturize and minimize fine lines and wrinkles.

Umbra Sheer is suitable for all skin types, including sensitive skin. It's free of chemical sunscreens, silicones, fragrance, and essential oils. Unlike Umbra Tinte, this sunscreen doesn't have a tint, making it ideal for those who prefer a more natural, invisible finish without any white residue or greasiness.

Find the best Umbra Sheer prices on Amazon

Chemical-Free Goodness

One of the key features of both Drunk Elephant Umbra Tinte and Umbra Sheer sunscreens is that they are chemical-sunscreen-free. This is an important distinction that sets these products apart from many other sunscreens on the market.

Chemical sunscreens typically contain ingredients like Oxybenzone, Avobenzone, Octisalate, Octocrylene, and Homosalate. These chemicals work by absorbing the sun's rays and then releasing them as heat, offering sun protection. However, chemical sunscreens can sometimes cause skin irritation or sensitization, especially for those with sensitive or reactive skin.

Drunk Elephant's Umbra Tinte and Umbra Sheer, on the other hand, use Zinc Oxide as their active ingredient. Zinc oxide is a naturally derived mineral that provides broad-spectrum protection by sitting on top of the skin and physically reflecting the sun's rays. This makes these sunscreens a safer option for those with sensitive skin or anyone looking to avoid potential skin irritants found in chemical sunscreens.

By choosing either Umbra Tinte or Umbra Sheer, you're opting for a sunscreen that protects your skin without relying on potentially sensitizing chemical ingredients. Instead, you'll enjoy the benefits of a physical sunscreen that uses the power of zinc oxide to shield your skin from harmful UVA and UVB rays, while also being kinder to both your skin and the environment.

Physical Sunscreen Woes

While physical sunscreens like Drunk Elephant's Umbra Tinte and Umbra Sheer offer numerous benefits, including being chemical-sunscreen-free and suitable for sensitive skin, they can sometimes come with a caveat: the dreaded white cast. This issue arises when the zinc oxide in the formula doesn't blend seamlessly into the skin, leaving a visible white or grayish residue.

Although Drunk Elephant's Umbra Tinte has a tinted formula designed to minimize the white cast issue, some customers have reported that it can still be visible, particularly on darker skin tones. The tint may not be universally flattering for everyone, and it's essential to blend the product well to achieve the desired even, glowing finish.

As for Umbra Sheer, while it's formulated to provide a transparent finish without altering the skin tone, some users have also reported experiencing a white cast, especially if not blended thoroughly. This issue might be more noticeable on medium to darker skin tones. To mitigate this effect, it's crucial to apply the product in small amounts and spread it evenly, allowing the formula to absorb into the skin properly.

Although Drunk Elephant's Umbra Tinte and Umbra Sheer sunscreens are designed to minimize the white cast commonly associated with physical sunscreens, it's essential to acknowledge that some users may still experience this issue. Proper application and blending techniques can help, but individual results may vary.

The Verdict

Both sunscreens are formulated without chemical sunscreens and silicones, offering UVA/UVB protection with zinc oxide. They're packed with the same set of antioxidants and moisturizing ingredients to keep your skin youthful and healthy, and they offer the same SPF of 30. The main difference lies in their finish: Umbra Tinte offers a gorgeous tinted glow, while Umbra Sheer provides an invisible, natural finish.

So, which one should you choose? If you're looking for a sunscreen with a touch of color to even out your skin tone and provide a radiant glow, Umbra Tinte is the way to go. However, if you prefer a completely natural, invisible finish without any tint, Umbra Sheer is your perfect match.

Remember, sunscreen is an essential part of your daily skincare routine, so make sure you're applying it every morning and reapplying throughout the day, especially during the sunny months. Stay protected, and let your skin shine!