Avene vs Eucerin 2023 (The Definitive Guide)

Both Avene and Eucerin market their products for sensitive skin, with hypoallergenic and dermatologically tested options in the skincare range. But which should you choose?

The ideal treatment for sensitive skin includes products that actively work to repair, hydrate, and protect the skin barrier. However, suppose you are searching for gentle yet effective products but arent sure where to begin. In that case, a soothing lotion paired with gentle cleansing milk might be the answer.

Alternatively, a repair cream that offers 24 hour moisture can work to relieve redness and itching. Unfortunately, the market is now oversaturated with ‘sensitive skin’ and hypoallergenic options making it difficult to purchase the right product.

This is where our comparison guide can help, and the good news is that Avene and Eucerin have a range of sensitive skincare products backed by science and clinical studies.

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

About the Brands

Today we will be comparing two brands, Avene and Eucerin, and their popular emulsions, lotions, and cleansers. But, first, let’s find out which one best suits your skincare needs with our comprehensive guide below.

Avene

According to Avene, the key ingredient to its success is the Thermal Spring Water developed over 30 years in the Avene Dermatological Laboratories.

“Avène Thermal Spring Water, naturally soothing, anti-irritating, is rich in components particularly recommended for the most sensitive skin.” - Avène.

Avene specifically focuses its skincare range on safety and tolerability for those dealing with sensitive, hyperactive, and reactive skin. The Avene range is free from steroids and anti-inflammatory drugs. Furthermore, you can find a wide range of information for allergies and immune reactions, redness, itchiness, irritation, and sensitized skin on their website to ensure you select the skincare product that is right for your skin type. The research behind Avene is very impressive, making the range popular worldwide.

Eucerin

Eucerin, another famous skincare brand, works to deliver a holistic-cosmetic approach by combining research from both dermatologists and pharmacists. So it is not surprising that the Eucerin range is dedicated to improving your skin condition; with over 100 years of research and product innovation, they are a leading skincare brand.

“Eucerin skin research experts make no compromises in researching, developing, and testing the products.” - Eucerin.

Eucerin has an extensive range of products to treat a wide array of skincare needs, including redness, dryness, dark spots, acne, skin texture, and an acute care range for complex skin concerns such as Atopic Dermatitis and Atopic Eczema

Suppose you require soothing skincare products such as a repair lotion, gentle cleanser, or replenishing cream. In that case, you may be experiencing dry skin, redness, irritation, or even allergies to commonly used ingredients. Understandably, finding a product based on research and science in treating complex skin concerns is significant

Keep scrolling to determine if Avene or Eucerin is the ideal choice for you and your skincare needs.

Avene vs Eucerin Moisturizer

Avene Tolerance Control Skin Recovery Cream vs Eucerin UltraSensitive Soothing Care

2024 update: Unfortunately, Avene's Tolerance Extreme Emulsion (which we previously reviewed) is now discontinued. It's closest ancestor is the Skin Recovery Cream, which, funnily enough, has also seen an upgrade and is now called the Avene Tolerance Control Skin Recovery Cream.

The Avene Tolerance Control Skin Recovery Cream is a high tolerance formula designed for combination skin. The emulsion is hydrating, soothing, preservative, and fragrance-free. Avene has created this fantastic product featuring its key ingredient Hydrating Thermal Spring Water, to soothe and soften skin. In addition, the cream contains D-SENSINOSE which immediately calm all sensations of skin discomfort, making it fantastic for most sensitive skin types.

The Eucerin UltraSensitive Soothing Care is designed for hypersensitive skin and those with a weakened skin barrier. If you experience hyper-reactivity to other products, redness, dry patches, irritation, or stress inflammation, the Eucerin UltraSensitive Soothing Care range is designed to provide relief from symptoms. Like Avene's Skin Recovery Cream, this product contains minimal ingredients and is free from preservatives and fragrance.

Eucerin UltraSensitive Soothing Care is specially developed for hypersensitive skin experiencing discomfort without signs of redness. In addition, the Avene Tolerance Control Skin Recovery Cream is designed to reduce redness and inflammation and acts as a gentle moisturizer.

Avene Xeracalm Lipid Replenishing Creme vs Eucerin Intensive Repair Lotion

Designed to treat dry, sensitive skin prone to atopic dermatitis and eczema, the Avene Xeracalm Lipid Replenishing Creme is specifically formulated to reduce the risk of allergic reactions. The instant benefit of this product is the anti-itching relief provided by the addition of Avene Thermal Spring Water. This key ingredient instantly calms the skin, adding hydration to the damaged skin barrier. In addition, lipids work to repair, nourish and build resistance, making sure your skin is calm and replenished.

Formulated for very dry, flaky skin, the Eucerin Intensive Repair Lotion is a hydrating formula that moisturizes, exfoliates, and restores radiance to the skin. This product is not specifically designed for itchy or eczema-prone skin but is suitable for sensitive skin types. The lotion is free from preservatives, fragrance, and dye and features (AHA) Alpha Hydroxy Acid to help improve skin texture.

Acids in skincare are not something to be concerned about; in fact, they have many benefits when used correctly, particularly when it comes to gentle exfoliation. AHA works on the uppermost layers of the skin’s surface and offers an effective treatment for dry, flaky, sun-damaged skin.

If you are experiencing hypersensitive, eczema-prone skin, the Avene Xeracalm is formulated to soothe reactions, while the Eucerin lotion targets very dry skin types. Both products are formulated for sensitive skin and are dermatologically tested.

Avene vs Eucerin Cleanser

A mild cleansing formula requires gentle cleansing without stripping the delicate skin on our face of essential oils and moisture. Unlike a face wash, a cleanser or gel should be non-foaming, soap-free, and have minimal ingredients.

2024 update: Avene's Milk Cleanser is new and improved! It now features 98% ingredients of natural origin and eco-designed packaging (which can never be a bad thing).

The Avene Gentle Milk Cleanser is made for very dry and sensitive skin. This lightweight formula claims to remove makeup and impurities without irritating the skin. The milk cleanser offers a soothing, velvety texture that is both hypoallergenic and non-comedogenic. Avene recommends using the Gentle Milk Cleanser as the first step in your skincare routine, followed by the Thermal Spring Water Spray and a hydrating serum or cream.

DermatoCLEAN is a range of skincare designed to be gentle but effective for sensitive skin. The products are clinically and dermatologically proven to reduce irritation dryness and leave the skin feeling hydrated and soft. The Eucerin DermatoCLEAN Mild Cleansing Milk is a rich formula suitable for daily cleansing. It is applied with a cotton pad to remove makeup and impurities. After application, the milk cleanser can be gently washed off the face with water. This cleanser contains Eucerins APG complex, which is fragrance and alcohol-free.

Deciding between the two never used to be straightforward, but we *love* Avene's new & improved formula, and we think you will too.

Avene vs Eucerin Conclusion

If you find your skin is sensitive or if you are managing skin concerns such as dermatitis or eczema, then a skin care product with minimal ingredients will limit unwanted reactions to parabens, preservatives, alcohol and synthetic dyes. Both Avene and Eucerin have a long standing reputation for dermatologically based skincare that treats a range of complicated skin conditions.

It is important to check the ingredients, whilst minimal, are suitable for your skin type. Overall, sensitive skin that battles redness and irritation my benefit from the Avene Thermal Spring Water whilst skin that is eczema prone or hyper reactive may benefit from the medically researched Eucerin range.

Other Avene Ranges

For very sensitive skin:
Try the Tolérance Range

For redness or rosacea:
Try the Antirougeurs Range

For acne and oily, blemish-prone skin:
Try the Cleanance Range

Other Eucerin Ranges

For sun protection:
Try Daily Protection

For eczema relief:
Try Eczema Relief

For body washing:
Try Advanced Cleansing

This article was originally published on February 14th 2022, but it has been reviewed and updated with the latest available information on January 26th 2024 by Sara Mckay, MA.