Aveeno Calm + Restore vs Ultra Calming

In the ever changing landscape of Aveeno products, it's not too surprising that the fairly niche Ultra Calming range has been caught in the crossfire. In particular, you may have noticed the unfortunate discontinuation of the relatively popular Ultra-Calming Daily Moisturizer from the line.

Today, we're here to lay out the alternative options, homing in especially on Aveeno's own recommendation: the Calm + Restore Redness Relief Moisturizing Cream.

This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.

Aveeno Calm + Restore vs Ultra-Calming Moisturizer

It's worth noting that you can still find the Ultra-Calming Daily Moisturizer at select retailers such as Amazon, but once existing stock runs out you're going to need a back up plan. Aveeno recommends that a good alternative would be the Calm+Restore Redness Relief Moisturizing Cream, so let's find out if it's actually any good (and whether or not it's actually a like-for-like replacement).

Comparison

First, let's talk about their texture. Both products come in a rich, creamy texture that's ideal for sensitive skin. The Calm + Restore Moisturizing Cream is designed for everyday use, just like the Ultra Calming moisturizer.

When it comes to ingredients, both products feature calming Feverfew as their hero ingredient (which was the big difference in our previous comparison, Positively Radiant vs Ultra Calming). This natural wonder ingredient is known to help improve the appearance of facial redness and soothes skin irritation, making it perfect for sensitive and irritated skin. The Calm + Restore Moisturizing Cream also contains nourishing Oat, Ceramides and Vitamin B5 for added hydration and skin-soothing benefits.

A significant difference between the two products is that the Ultra Calming moisturizer contains SPF 15, providing broad-spectrum sun protection, while the Calm + Restore Moisturizing Cream does not. If you're switching to Calm + Restore, you'll need to use a separate sunscreen to protect your skin from harmful UV rays.

Another notable difference is that the Ultra Calming moisturizer contains fragrance, while the Calm + Restore Moisturizing Cream is fragrance-free. This makes the Calm + Restore cream a more suitable option for those with extra-sensitive skin that may react negatively to fragrances.

In conclusion, Aveeno's Calm + Restore Redness Relief Moisturizing Cream seems to be a promising alternative to the discontinued Ultra Calming Daily Face Moisturizer SPF 15. While you'll need to use a separate sunscreen with the Calm + Restore cream, its fragrance-free formula and skin-loving ingredients make it a suitable option for sensitive and irritated skin. Give it a try and let us know how it works for you!

Calm + Restore Redness Relief Moisturizing Cream by Aveeno

Shop Check price on amazon.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Moisturizes & visibly soothes facial redness.

What makes it special? Instantly hydrate skin & visibly soothe facial redness. This redness relief face moisturizer formulated with Vitamin B5 & ceramide features a calming feverfew & nourishing oat formula to calm dry skin.

Which skin types? For sensitive, irritated dry skin.

Find the best price on Amazon

Ultra-Calming Daily Face Moisturizer SPF 15 by Aveeno (Discontinued)

Shop Check price on amazon.com

Our rating: ★★★★★

Price: $$$$

Visibly reduces redness.

What makes it special? For sensitive skin, nothing’s more important than balance. That’s where this ULTRA-CALMING® Daily Moisturizer comes in. Be prepared to glow with Aveeno's exclusive CALMING FEVERFEW® formula, clinically proven to rebalance and soothe irritated skin. Gentle enough for daily use, you’ll see reduced redness in as little as one week.

Which skin types? For sensitive skin types.

Find the best price on Amazon